Why do people think Christians want to end all Stem Cell research?
I've seen this used throughout the site. However, Christians are only opposed to embryonic stem cell research.
What about others such as adult stem cells? I have yet to meet a Christian that wants to end those.
- Login to post comments
You do realize there are other methods of stem cell extraction? That's my point. Christians aren't against those.
My point is many people think that Christians want to end ALL stem cell research. I am demostrating how this is not the case.
Quote:Sorry to double post.
The 'farming' is cloning the stem cell and I think you'll be able to see why they don't like anything that says 'cloning'.
Hwang Ku Suk's(sp?) data discrepencies set back the research advocates a decade in my opinion. He was working on the cloning
Quote:Uhm, it has nothing to do with theism. He's the guy that claimed that he successfully cloned some cells, only to find out that he was lying. He was making some progress, but everything had to be thrown out and now they have to start over. I kind of doubt that christians are going to give cloning, of any sort, a free pass, though (as Deludedgod mentioned).According to wikipedia he's a Buddhist (Former Christian). I don't see how this has to do with the issue.
Deludedgod didn't mention cloning Darth Josh did. I don't see any Christian objections to stem cell cloning, it is human cloning they are against.
- Login to post comments
Many Christians are opposed to ESC (Embryonic Stem Cells) because the harvesting of them requires the destruction of the embryo from which they are harvested. I personally find this position rather odd since the foetus' used for ESC is one which was already aborted, so it might as well be used for some good.
So, as an alternative, they support umbilical cord stem cell, haemopoitic stem cells and adult stem cells. I personally don't care between the three so long as stem cell resarchers get the stem cells they need, and unfortunately, the American block on ESC is a major block to the desperate need for stem cells. They are the most potent stem cells.
"Physical reality” isn’t some arbitrary demarcation. It is defined in terms of what we can systematically investigate, directly or not, by means of our senses. It is preposterous to assert that the process of systematic scientific reasoning arbitrarily excludes “non-physical explanations” because the very notion of “non-physical explanation” is contradictory.
-Me
Books about atheism
It's because they feel that an unborn embryo is a child. It's like abortion to them to use an embryo for research and then discard it. They claim that "man has high value", so therefore we shouldn't kill anyone before they are born. This is contradictory in a number of ways. First of all, doesn't the unborn baby just go to heaven (according to them)? Secondly, I don't see much value in their belief that man was formed from dirt and is irrefutably wretched and evil.
Atheism is a non-prophet organization.
I heard they are working on a method to replicate adult stem cells on demand so they don't need to harvest them, they can just 'farm' them.
Did you even read the topic? What about the other forms of stem cell research?
Cpt_Pineapple,
How many christians do you speak to on the subject?
Of those, how many even understand the premise behind it?
Despite the work in partial harvesting, the christians that I speak to are still operating under the same allegedly 'moral' arguments against it. They have NO CLUE as to the latest developments.
The same goes with preachers.
THAT'S WHY!
Atheist Books, purchases on Amazon support the Rational Response Squad server, which houses Celebrity Atheists.
Sorry to double post.
The 'farming' is cloning the stem cell and I think you'll be able to see why they don't like anything that says 'cloning'.
Hwang Ku Suk's(sp?) data discrepencies set back the research advocates a decade in my opinion. He was working on the cloning.
Atheist Books, purchases on Amazon support the Rational Response Squad server, which houses Celebrity Atheists.
You do realize there are other methods of stem cell extraction? That's my point. Christians aren't against those.
According to wikipedia he's a Buddhist (Former Christian). I don't see how this has to do with the issue.
According to wikipedia he's a Buddhist (Former Christian). I don't see how this has to do with the issue.