To get to the root of the matter...

Xians know that they cannot back up their claims except with other faith-based claims. Now, I've seen this work well with other Xians, but not with atheists.

The atheists I know use rational + logic formula to dissolve Xian arguements. Xians utilize the same formula to attempt to prove their claim. This has never, ever worked. Everytime I have seen a Xian use a logical process to support whatever he might be talking about, he/she gets their ass handed to them.

I want Xians to know the only way to convince me of the supernatural will be to show me evidence.