Yeah, this show is relatively "old", but I have some thoughts on it.

• This guy talks WAY too much and interrupts like crazy! You guys were extremely patient in dealing with a guy with such bizarre pseudo-philosophical views, who never let you finish a sentence and was always changing the direction of the conversation. I found myself rolling my eyes and scoffing throughout.
• As for Hitler being Christian, he did admit he was Christian but later spoke out against the religion. From a logical standpoint, Hitler used religion to sway the masses and accept a majority of German Christian support. He wasn't necessarily a believer.
• On the bullshit story that is Adam & Eve, here's a point I wished I could have made: If Adam & Eve had no concept about good and evil before eating the fruit, then they would not have understood the "evil" of disobeying god. Doh! They would have relied on their curiosity to make the decision, not their morality, since they had no concept of morality yet. Yes, it's a ridiculous point to make on fictional characters without psyches (and who apparently lived 900 years) but theists will be theists...
• I too would describe myself as a metaphysical naturalist. I think that's a good summation of my worldview.
• I was hoping someone would interject on morality being a result of evolution due to its biological advantages, as well as a result of memes and possibly an unintended byproduct of some other evolutionary benefit. Religion is similar in this way.
• I had trouble listening to the entire show because listening to this nice but annoying man was almost impossible to do without wanting to choke him.
• I loved the whole "cast of characters" remark.

Nice show. I admire the patience of the entire squad. I would've had trouble remaining composed.