Can you answer without the Ad hominem?
FACT: There is NO Physical/Tangible "Evidence" that God exists.
Question: "How can you Disprove something that does not exist?"
Is not the argument of Atheist vs. Theist a moot point, since neither side can produce evidence because the fact in question states that there is no argument?
- Login to post comments
Ladies and gentlemen, our new friend Guy is a "Calvinist" and engages in conversations with snarky, anthropomorphic stuffed tigers. Cut him some slack!
(Sorry Guy, couldn't resist slipping in a Calvin & Hobbes jab there)
:^)
-HCG
Excellent Question!
I "believe" that God puts leaders into office...
Pharoah of Egypt Before, during, and after Joseph in the bible was contrary to God. Yet he ruled over the Jews.
If God wants an Atheist in an office, He will put one there!
Now...
Here is one thing that many Christians dislike about me!
I keep politics and religion seperate!
Titus 3:1 Put them in mind to be subject to principalities and powers, to obey magistrates, to be ready to every good work,
Before my renunciation of the Southern Baptist Convention, I was a hard core right wing idiot!
This last election, I voted for 2 RNC, 11 DNC, and 4 Independents!
When I vote, I vote for what is best for my fellow Human, my fellow Christians will always be under the care of God. But ALL citizens of the USA are deserving of my respect towards their general welfare.
Sorry Fellow Christians, I just get worse!
I support Abortion in the case of Rape, Incest, and Life of the Mother. But! If the public votes to keep abortion legal, then the public has spoken, I must obey the laws of man. God will judge the woman getting the abortion, as well as the man who agreed with her.
John 8:7 So when they continued asking him, he lifted up himself, and said unto them, He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her.
John 8:10 When Jesus had lifted up himself, and saw none but the woman, he said unto her, Woman, where are those thine accusers? hath no man condemned thee?
John 8:11 She said, No man, Lord. And Jesus said unto her, Neither do I condemn thee: go, and sin no more.
Homosexuals getting married? Let them! But NEVER FORCE THE CHURCH to perform the ceremony! If a church chooses, then let it be so! If a "civil union" is in order, let it be so. We MUST follow the laws of man. God puts those in charge for a reason, and mine is not to question that reason!
Religion and state? No. I have no problem with the ten commandments in an Alabama courthouse being removed! The "In God We trust" taken off the money, the religious symbols being removed from government property. But TAKE THEM ALL OFF! Including the pagan Goddess "Pomona" on the Los Angeles, California Great Seal. Remove ALL religious symbols. If we are to seperate church and state, it must be ALL religions & beliefs.
Bush is an idiot, we should not be at war, our government is corrupted by big business, tobacco is killing our people, big sugar is killing our children, fossil fuels are destroying the planet God gave us! And the modern day incarnation of the New Testament church is paralyzed with sin!
There was my answer, was it all you guys hoped for? Or did I dissapoint? Did it turn out that I was a normal everyday human like so many others on earth?
Christians are human, they think, they choose, they make mistakes, they pay for their mistakes.
He is probably in the bathroom. Honestly, Brian37, you and a few others on this site are like theist colon cleanse medicine.
Sorry, I don't have anything more enlightening to add, but I think you and the others have covered it pretty well.
It never ceases to amuse me that some people come here expecting one thing but run into reality when we dont act like sheep.
Thanks for the giggle.
OH CRAP! WHY ARENT THEY SUBMITTING!
"If I say the right thing, or pray at the right time, maybe I'll get lucky and peel one off of the herd".
Atheists have been around throughout human history and will continue to question. Too bad for you that we live in a country where you cant stop that, and good for us that you cant stop that.
"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under Brian James Rational Poet, @Brianrrs37 on Twitter and my blog at www.brianjamesrationalpoet.blog
I do not preach here, this is not the venue for it, this venue to me is one of fellowship.
I did, and I repented, keep reading, and check my past posts where I admitted my showing of "Bad Fruits" before he presented it to me.
But I have yet to see his apology for violaing my copyright, but then again, I am answering posts in order. I will see as I continue down the list.
So that's a no then?
Freedom of religious belief is an inalienable right. Stuffing that belief down other people's throats is not.
Why are xtians allowed to go around and preach and impose their beliefs?
Can't you people just respect the rest of us enough to maybe try not do this all the gently caressing time??
Throughout this whole thread you impose your beliefs on me. I have proof! (I am after all a freethinker)
You impose your beliefs on everyone here!
You keep doing it! Almost every post!
Stop it damn it!
Stop making me post!
Don't get me all riled up by lying. You are preaching. You are imposing. And that is the only reason why you are here. You don't care about my philosopy or the practise of it.
It is you that has the double standard. It is you that keeps misleadings and implying. It is you that keeps preaching.
Why do xtians do this? You guys do it all the gently caressing time! And then DENY doing it!
Judge: god, you have been accused of existence! What do you have to say for yourself?
god: I am innocent until proven guilty, your honour!
You clearly have not kept up on copyright law. The introduction of "Electronic Serial Numbers" coupled with "Identity Verification" can hold weight in court for items that have not been submitted to the Copyright office.
The threat is by no means idle, I shew grace unto him by not pursuing the infringement.
The point would be that he show respect for the works of authors, and respect the request of them for not "retransmitting" them. A simple "Hey, do you mind if I post here, what you said on your weblog" from him would have brought a "Sure, go right ahead, I have nothing to hide, lets discuss it" from me.
But he chose not to, just as I chose not to pursue the infringement. We both made choices, and we are both responsible for them. He infringed, I pardoned.
Glad to hear you say that. But I your answer sounds more like "THERE I SAID IT, HAPPY NOW!"
Your post comes across just like white people objecting to Tigar Woods playing golf, "OK, BLACKS CAN PLAY GOLF, HAPPPY NOW? WHATS NEXT?"
I am not saying that is your intent, but it certainly comes across as an angrey consession rather than a mutial concusion of the rights of all humans.
Nice start, but hopefully you'll really mean it someday insted of merely avoiding sounding like the bad guy.
Look, I dont want anything but neutrality for our goverment and it's courts and symbols. I dont want an atom symbol on our flag or money. I dont want to rid America of its diversity. I do want people to consider those outside their religious labels as demanded in our Constitution "No Religious Test".
So although I am glad to hear you say that, I do wonder if you really mean it.
"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under Brian James Rational Poet, @Brianrrs37 on Twitter and my blog at www.brianjamesrationalpoet.blog
Why not?
Am I not allowed?
Tell an administrator to ask me to leave, and I will honor their request. It is their digital property, if I trespass, I will vacate.
Read what I posted on that, and do the research!
LOL, PWNED!!
You I believe (and of course correct me if I am wrong as I hope I am) misunderstand the question. Its not that you are unwelcome at this point. Its the fact that it sounds like your not open to questions and in someways other than debating some of the semantics of belief which have been argued ad nauseam here, that your not really here to debate things as people are elected so why bother (most likely not represented right but perhaps you get my point).
Generally we don't have issues with theists posting things or whatever. Usually the only time people are asked to leave is if they are trolling the boards or breaking the rules, of which as far as I can tell hasn't been the case. Again those who may know (as most of my posts today has been from work so im only doing replies for the most part right now) let me know.
Go here if you would like to donate to help pay for server costs
Then I will post the link here upon its completion. And no, there will be no editing of the original post. The post will stand to show myself, and others the error that I made.
Nice to know that you have no respect for the works of other authors, and could not find it in your benevolence of trying to help poor misguided Christians like myself by being an example, and asking first about retransmitting my works.
You are allowed here, but you wont get away with preaching. If you resort to that you are garunteed to get booted. Debate us, provide evidence for your claims. But do not expect us to be passive.
"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under Brian James Rational Poet, @Brianrrs37 on Twitter and my blog at www.brianjamesrationalpoet.blog
I did read it(PWNED), I did the research(PWNED).
I still think you are faulty in your thinking it is copyright infringement.
Your welcome, and Thanks to you for sharing your opinion with me. No insult taken...
Tho interestingly enough, and if you have posted this elsewhere feel free to link me, why are you here? What is your goal? To debate your position? To listen to others? To find out how you can better debate your position by listening to others?
I think that might be what Maragon was asking. What do you want to accomplish? If its to learn and throw out your thoughts on things great. If your goal is to come here and preach and try to grab some converts, I think you might be barking up the wrong tree (tho from it sounds like you generally don't do that as we would have to be elected anyways..)
Go here if you would like to donate to help pay for server costs
We didnt see this comming at all. We never see anyone dodge direct claims and then try and turn it into a personal vendeta on our part.
Or maybe the fact is you have no evidence for your deity, and so to avoid the subject you accuse people here of things they are not doing.
Ok, we can give you another shot. Please prove us wrong, we really love being proven wrong.
Please stick to the subject of showing us evidence for your deity you claim is real. Otherwise you are wasting our time and yours.
"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under Brian James Rational Poet, @Brianrrs37 on Twitter and my blog at www.brianjamesrationalpoet.blog
See I thought it was the voters who put the leader in office. I mean, since people have free will, God can't choose for them who they vote for right? Oh well. More fool me. Incidentally there have been a fair few non-religious presidents George Washington wasn't religious nor was Thomas Jefferson (not a president I know, but a founding father). Also why would God choose a leader for one society whose constitution puts him out of power (i.e. The Separation of Church and State) but not do for other societies whose constitutions do the same.
Also, why would God put that bumbling idiot Mr Bush in power. He's clearly got a below average IQ! I'm glad my couontry has a slightly lesser idiot in power. In fact even this idiot has pushed through a fair amount of welfare reforms.
Atheist Books
1. I have no evidence, and no evidence will there ever be.
2. If I am forced to speak only on issues of the forums choosing, and must remain silent as others here continue, then No. Freedom is removed from me, ergo the forum loses its value as a forum.
3. As soon as I finish the rest of the posts here in this thread that need an answer, I will. Then I can just email the link to the website for Sapient to see.
This got lost in the minor flame war. Could I get a response?
My Artwork
It's not that you're not allowed, it's just that I don't see your purpose here other than to antagonize.
And I was right about your claims for copyright.
I can say that I've copyrighted this post.
Luckily, just saying something doesn't make it true.
http://atheismisrational.blogspot.com/
Oh, I do. Many of my brethren can attest that I am quite the rebel, and refuse to submit to the will of "Man's Dogma".
I am not the most liked in the far right wing circle that I defected from.
What the gently caressing?! There's three gently caressing pages of them.
They have answered your questions. Numerous times. Read the posts.
Stop denying that no one's answered your question.
Judge: god, you have been accused of existence! What do you have to say for yourself?
god: I am innocent until proven guilty, your honour!
1. If you have no evidence, then again goes back to why are you here if you have no evidence and feel that there should need not be evidence. This implies that you can't/won't really discuss God or religion because to you, if your elected its implied on that person and if not, that person is lost anyways.
2. This relates to one. If you can't debate on God because you have no evidence and have no wish to show any evidence on the idea, then this would imply if you were to stick around to discuss something other than religion as you don't want to debate that. We have things on science and politics as well as other subjects on irrational beliefs so you could stick around for that.
3. This is of course your choice and not much we can do about it apparently other than not be honest.
Go here if you would like to donate to help pay for server costs
To hang out with the people the majority of my fellow Christians are too Pious to be seen in the presence of.
What is so bad about being here? I dunno, but I know many of the folks I used to run with in the far right wing would screech at the thought of a Christian fellowshipping with sinners and publicans, even tho the Lord didn't seem to have a problem with it.
I have no evidence, and NO Christian EVER will. And I am leaving just as you suggested after I at least show the courtesy of getting to the end of the thread.
Thats fine if you want to hang out. I think the concern some may have, including myself, is that it seems you might be a little on the pious as well when on your page you generally refer to us (I realize you specifically sight Kelly and to a lesser extent Brian, however at least for a group of us here, our thoughts and "morals" as you call it follow closely with theirs so hence why I use us) as tools of Satan. Obviously we atheists do not believe in satan or hell or the like but it does seem a little odd that on one side you say we hang with satan but on the other side you want to hang out. (I relize you have backed up on the comment but it still exists whether you want it to or not). Again others, including myself to a certain degree, might see this as evidence (tho very superficially I admit) that your goal here is to preach.
Go here if you would like to donate to help pay for server costs
There can never be evidence, I cannot change that fact.
To discuss it here requires evidence, which will never be! Ergo, I am forced out of the loop.
I no nothing of science, my politics are wierd, and generally, the consensus is that others would feel more comfortable with my departure.
Causing strife is not my goal, ergo the strife I cause has upset the balance of the community. You did fine before I was here, and will do even better after my departure.
My interests are that of Bible, theology, chess, and homeschooling. Not much room for that here seeing as my main interest can never be proven.
But I leave you with this....
If a Christian claims that they have physical/tangible evidence of the existence of God, take it from a Christian. They are lying.
Huh? I didn't see a response.
People are so freakin touchy around here. Fuck you.
My Artwork
My fellow Christians think me far from it!
Even Chrisitains are used as tools of Satan when they fall into temptation. My post on the debate is the case in point. My criticism of all 4 debating people (Which you folks still left out Ray & Kirk to this very minute) was quite the bad showing overall.
It was good enough for the Lord, it should be good enough for me.
I guess your "thesim" is other than "Judeo-Christianity"
At least I did one thing right! I never did use profanity in my dialog. Guess there was one thing I did right aye?
Oops. Did I say that?
You are correct. I am definately not what passes for a traditional theist. If you wish to discuss it outside of this forum, visit my myspace page (http://www.myspace.com/wavefreak58). I have no desire to discuss religious themes here.
My Artwork
On that thing on your site, I did not see you claiming that Ray and Kirk were tools of Satan (the only point you had was that Kirk and Ray used arguments that Satan was prepared for and implied that Satan was the one responsible for Kelly and Brian's rebuttals).
Go here if you would like to donate to help pay for server costs
Then leave!
Way to be a xtian! Way to be blind too! Way to read!
And gently caress you too!
(kill them with kindness)
Judge: god, you have been accused of existence! What do you have to say for yourself?
god: I am innocent until proven guilty, your honour!
Are you a moron or just pretending to be one? I never claimed to be a xtian. That's why I can say fuck. Or even fuck you. See you in hell, bucko. Maybe we'll be in the same fire pit.
My Artwork
now you are trolling.... now i won't hold back.... you fuck off.. you are not welcome here... i will ask the mods to remove you... you are not contributing anything constructive...
leave already! didn't you say you were?! Just go!
:P
Judge: god, you have been accused of existence! What do you have to say for yourself?
god: I am innocent until proven guilty, your honour!
Read my other posts, freak. Never said I was leaving either. I'm pretty sure fuck is not banned. I've seen it used several times.
My Artwork
The both of you need to stop this childish shit. It helps no one, makes you look stupid and wastes my time dealing with it when I could also be contributing something meaningful. Nevermind breaking rules of the boards but it certainly breaks the original request of not using ad hominems.
Go here if you would like to donate to help pay for server costs
....the internets are serious business?
I apologize. I lost it for a minute. Though it was strangely libertating to be childish fo a minute. Is their a sandbox around here? I want to play ...
My Artwork
Hey whiney, worrying about the debates you're having seems to be enough trouble, this aint the time for you to take your head out of your ass about hing copy right laws, which you seem to know nothing about. Comments like "you have no respect for the works of other authors" are exceedingly dishonest.
1. I posted the URL to your post.
2. I was speaking directly to you.
3. Even if I wasn't speaking to you I was directly quoting you and attributing you the credit.
4. I have what's called "fair use" law in my favor.
Stop whining. You should probably repent for the last post too, I'm sure god saw right through that sly exterior to reveal the dishonest interior. I don't think you can really be this stupid about how copyright works.
Vote for Democrats to save us all from the anti-American Republican party!
Please become a Patron of Brian Sapient
Sue me, Guy. I'd love to bring this issue out in a court on public record. My countersuit would take your offering plate to the cleaners.
Your comment of:
should be directed to the Department of Homeland Security in my opinion.
I took a screen shot of your blog post just in case you did the typical thing of deleting it after caught.
You may have repented to your alleged lord and saviour, but my forgiveness comes harder.
I've been relatively nice to people like you, Guy. Perhaps for too long. You're making it increasingly difficult to be kind and compassionate regardless of ideology. Your pleas for tolerance of your own beliefs while denigrating others is nothing short of hypocrisy.
Contrary to any preconceived notions of yours, we strive to be as tolerant of individual beliefs as possible. Ad hominems are personal insults directed at an individual that are baseless. Your own blog entry provided the basis for attacking you and your alleged beliefs.
Denial of actions attributed to the belief structure of christianity does not lessen the effect of those actions on other humans.
In a Calvinist mindset, you would never have made those insults in the first place if you were truly one of the 'elect' in my opinion. Thank you for providing another anecdotal flaw in Calvin's doctrine. Repentance has so little meaning when you believe that you are chosen already.
I won't stop trying to bring people to reasoned judgments regarding their beliefs until I'm dead. Perhaps one day, your cries will be for mercy and it will be me there helping you. I'll do it, but only because I'd hate myself if I didn't. Certainly not because of some delusional story in a book.
Have a nice fucking day.
Atheist Books, purchases on Amazon support the Rational Response Squad server, which houses Celebrity Atheists.
After reading this thread, i feel strangely compelled to light myself on fire.
That was arlready done by some boneheaded buddhists who thought they were teaching humanity a lesson. All they did was commit suicide. I could understand that if they were terminal. But damn, lighting yourself on fire as a demonstration? That is just as retarded as slaming a plane into a building.
I do hope most Buddhists and Muslims wont copycat stupidity like that. I might find their beliefs to be silly, but I certanly dont think killing yourself when you are not ill does anything but needlessly shorten your life.
Please dont light yourself on fire. I get enough stupid stories about violence in the news on all the networks 24/7 already.
"We are a nation of Christians and Muslims, Jews and Hindus -- and nonbelievers."Obama
Check out my poetry here on Rational Responders Like my poetry thread on Facebook under Brian James Rational Poet, @Brianrrs37 on Twitter and my blog at www.brianjamesrationalpoet.blog
I love how that Daily Way guy was asked about this several times on the forums and never answered the question. All that stuff about "the elect" only getting into heaven and saying that even an atheist can be "elect" even if they don't want to be. It really makes no sense. I would really like to understand more about where this line of thinking comes from.
www.myspace.com/proglodyte
Gizmo touched on this already but I wanted to throw my 2 cents in. Please don't assume a role akin to moderator if you aren't one. It's an unkind threat and very undesirable. We have enough mods to oversee everyone, including all the theists. We're constantly juggling free speech vs. trolling and determining who should stay. If you really have the need to write something like that again, just send it to a mod, the public threat is uncool.
Vote for Democrats to save us all from the anti-American Republican party!
Please become a Patron of Brian Sapient