How do you avoid generalizations?

Technarch
Posts: 127
Joined: 2007-02-06
User is offlineOffline
How do you avoid generalizations?

It's too easy to say "Christians think this" or "Muslims think this," and even "practice this" or "believe this" isn't always accurate as there are always exceptions.  Even saying "in general, Christians believe" still isn't helpful.   But getting to specific examples tends to exclude the majority, so pointing to a specific event such as a Christianity inspired murder, or the Crusades, or Westboro Baptist Church, or Ted Haggard, or Pat Robertson, or Hitler, it doesn't really apply to enough people other than being an extreme example.   For example, "Christians are generally good" (broad generalization) but look at the Crusades (extreme example).  How do you avoid these in an argument?


aiia
Superfan
aiia's picture
Posts: 1923
Joined: 2006-09-12
User is offlineOffline
Technarch wrote: It's too

Technarch wrote:
It's too easy to say "Christians think this" or "Muslims think this," and even "practice this" or "believe this" isn't always accurate as there are always exceptions.
Yes if the speaker means "all xians", "all muslims", but people tend to talk in generalities to shorten the lengthy oration that would be needed to be precise. If there's a doubt about what the speaker is saying then you must ask if he/she means in general or all.
Quote:
Even saying "in general, Christians believe" still isn't helpful. But getting to specific examples tends to exclude the majority, so pointing to a specific event such as a Christianity inspired murder, or the Crusades, or Westboro Baptist Church, or Ted Haggard, or Pat Robertson, or Hitler, it doesn't really apply to enough people other than being an extreme example. For example, "Christians are generally good" (broad generalization) but look at the Crusades (extreme example). How do you avoid these in an argument?
You can't avoid it. If there's something that's not understood then start asking questions.

People who think there is something they refer to as god don't ask enough questions.