Q for deconverts: religion & self-perpetuating probs
BGH's thread made me think of a question that I've had for some time now. This is a question to everyone that was once religious but has since become an atheist.
I/we know that religion resolves a lot of problems that it creates, which serves to keep people believing. The biggest one that I noticed in other people growing up was guilt over natural feelings. The christian boys would see some attractive girl, start talking like sailors, and then practically break down in tears over the guilt that they feel and start praying. Heck, I've even seen some doing this after simply thinking something. It seemed clear to me that there were patterns of repression, compulsion, and guilt, obviously a mechanism to keep the person praying for forgiveness. That's just one example, but the result of this has been most religious people going on about how religion provides "so much" that "athiems can't", completely unaware that these things simply aren't problems in the athiest perspective. What I've been wondering is to what extent? What issues did you consider to be of the utmost importance when you were religious that simply became non-issues when you became atheist?
I know that I saw an article about a book that covered things like this. Although the book itself was about political corruption, it went into how corrupt leaders on the right use these mechanisms to control people, saying that religious people are the easiest to manipulate because of their religion. If anyone knows what this book is, I would love to know so that I can get a copy.
Anyway, what was your experience? What "issues" that religion addressed simply ceased to be issues once the religion was dropped?
- Login to post comments
Old habits die hard, so it took awhile to get rid of the problems religion caused in my life. To be honest, I was so thoroughly indoctrinated, I still have a lot of problems religion created, plus some created by leaving religion. Fun, huh?
The good news is that after many years, I finally banished my fear of hell. It was also a relief to not have to watch every word and thought, but again, it took time.
For some reason, there seems to be a disconnect between "head knowledge" and "heart knowledge." Long after I had cognitively banished any belief in hell, I still feared it and worried that the rapture would happen and I'd be left behind. I knew the fears were irrational, but knowing didn't help.
What helped me the most was applying emotional cures to emotional problems. I was afraid of something irrational. The only thing that worked was laughing at those beliefs, ridiculing them, being angry that I had been indoctrinated to believe such harmful crap. Sometimes only emotion can solve an emotional issue. Weird, huh?
Books on atheism, purchases on Amazon support the Rational Response Squad server.
I would love to be able to comment here (since you gained inspiration from my post) about some of the problems I had but I was never really 'fundie' so I wasn't racked with the guilt of some true believers.
I never really believed, I tried, but it just didn't happen for me. I always rationalized my version of 'god' to fit what I knew about the real world. Eventually I realized I was rationalizing something in which I had no belief.