I think it looks great! What would making just the A in rational in all red look like, and leave everything else the same. Just curious. But still love it!

Joe

  nope.. if you're gonna add something, it has to be instantly relative to the rest of the logo. You don't want it to look like a collage.

Interesting idea.

The logo type with the second line kerned out to match the first works ok. I kind of like the star trek like quality to the "A" and the badge-like quality (I don't know why it makes me think of a badge.)

But:

* It doesn't scan well. It is a mish-mash of styles and looks like three separate logos. Each has a different feel, color and edge treatment. The type is very square, the swash A is round and spikey and the evolution diagram is rough and distorted.

* There isn't enough separation between the "Rational Responders" text and the swash A.

* The human evolution graphic doesn't meld with the rest of the logo. The emboss and texture are a kludge to try and compensate for a lack of a coherent design and don't work.

* The swash A looks a bit like an ampersand.

I get what you are trying to do, combining the Rational Responders text with a spiffy variation on the atheist A along with a reference to your science-based approach in the evolution graphic. As it stands I think you are trying to combine too many ideas. Rather than try to make your graphic tell your whole story, simplify your graphic and use consistent branding to get people to associate it with your story. If you aren't comfortable with that, then I'd say you should come up with a way to integrate the A concept with the evolution picture so they form a cohesive rather than separate looking design. 

 

If it were me, I'd leave out the evolving illustration; it's overused.  I'd put something more unique.  Other than that, it's a very simple and effective design so far.

edit:  You know, come to think of it, it DOES look like a Star Trek logo...

I don't like the big A in the background. Looks like Star Trek related stuff.

The "evolution" image looks like the primate is evolving in to a zombie.

Over all I'd say "you can do better".

What ^they said. 

 I like my logos simpler and more symbolic, here are two variations of what you put up, keep in mind I pulled these out of my ass in less then half an hour, if you are interested I can get you the pre-layer merged Gimp images.
 

Badges, we don't need no stinking badges.

I like the badge, But meh, times change. It up to you dude. I like it, but I also like the badge so, probably not the best opinion here.

Awesome logo is awesome. That is that can be said about it. That is all anyone could possibly know about it.

I also feel that the evolution picture is overused and makes the whole thing too busy. I like the A in the background, but maybe a different color. 

Perhaps, if there was some clever way to incorporate the pro-science message into "Rational Responders" or the "A."........

@ Ktulu

I like the circle A on the side. I don't think you even need the super imposed version in back. Your idea makes for a much cleaner design that scans well, though I think I'd stretch out the spacing on "Responders" more like in the original.

One quick way to evaluate a logo is to see if it works in Black and White (Or "single color&quot, to see if the general shape of the logo, as opposed to the fancy emboss effects and textures, works. Your circle A on the side (without the superimposed giant A) works well in that respect (though I'd adjust the thickness of the circle A and the text to be a better match for eachother). The logo in the OP fails that test.

Hi Brian, I know you're not asking for advice, but as a design professional for the past 25 yrs I don't think you're on winner there. It's far too complicated, there is too much competition for attention which makes it impossible to remember. The most effective and memorable logos are always simple, when there is less to remember there is less to forget! Strong simple shapes and colours are the way to go.

I do have some ideas if you'd like to see them, I'm happy to donate my time.

enzo,

I'm all eyes.  Post em right here if you can.

But something as simple as this should be the goal. It won't date so fast and has more of a lasting impression. The evolve illustration has been done to death and nobody really owns it, it's just part of the visual pollution out there.

Having a unique symbol like this or something like it means you'll be remembered. It's meaning is quite simple, Rational Responders ultimate goal is an Atheist World.

Just remember, a logo can't say too much. It should be nothing more than visual mark that identifies an organisation.

 P.S. It would make a great Tshirt.

Wow.....

I really like that design. 

                             I am no type of artist or designer  BUT;  shouldn't the stylized letter(s) be  R R S?  I don't get the  'A' connection.

 Enzo, nice looking logo.  I had to scale the image size for this thread and it cut of the right side a little, but good looking image/logo idea.

How about someone trying, if they can, to put a double helix dna strand in shape of both the R's in Rational Responders. Or simply the helix being the stuck out part of the leg of the R's. Or the backbone of the R's? "R" ational "R"esponse Squad? Or a helix underlining the title?

Cool concept Brian.

Maybe we'll use the advanced polling functions of the new site to help pick a winner if a few designs become available.  I'm very open to all sorts of designs and ideas here.  

Once again... the badge isn't going anywhere, but I'd like a new logo that represents an image difference that I think is necessary in society today.  There is a different feeling in the world today than there was 6-7 years ago. 

Brian, do you remember your role in the name Rational Response Squad?  I don't remember the story exactly right now, but I think it's awesome how you've been around since that time and are here by my side today coming up with logo ideas.  Thanks.

I remember you telling me that we had a conversation about creating a name and I was a third responsible for part of the entire name, but do I remember our exact conversation? No. That was back when I was still living in VA.

And as far as being by your side, what can I say.  You have provided, not just me, but countless atheists a voice. Now excuse me, I have a kitten to barbecue.

How about black ray ban(Blues Bros) glasses with white Rs or red, in the lenses and Rational Response Squad under them. Or aviator glasses with the same?

Or the old timey hand held bifocals with the handle with the Rs in the lenses?

Or a spiral galaxy with a red R in the center.

Or like Einstein's formula. E=MC2..........."R=RRS" Or "Truth=RRS". Or tatooed fists each letter on each finger "Rational" and Response Squad under the fists.

Or a spiral galaxy with a red R in the center.

Or like Einstein's formula. E=MC2..........."R=RRS" Or "Truth=RRS". Or tatooed fists each letter on each finger "Rational" and Response Squad under the fists.

Owls symbolize wisdom. How about an owl with a red or white r in it's eyes ?

@ enzoconti

I like your circle A. It is a bold design with simple, memorable lines. But, how does it scan? I saw an evil smiley face, then someone bending over and mooning me. Could just be me, though...

LOL, now you're just being silly

A is the atheism symbol  

I like this also, but I would like to see them overlapped.  The way you have it, it looks way too much like a T-shirt,  I would like to see it more compact.  Really good first draft though

This is how it would look on a T Shirt, it can be white on black (as shown) or in reverse. All other applications are according to needs, brochures, websites, web banners etc, it will work across many formats.

It's been done a million times, but this is just a re-hash to make it more contemporary.

It probably has been overdone also, but what about a circle with a cut out cross, to symbolize no religion as the main focus of rational response.  Kind of like the no smoking sign but with a cross.  It would put the atheism thing right at the front of the symbol

Unlike Atheism, there is no unifying symbol of all religion. I like the concept, but not the cross. You need to express disgust for all religions to be "confrontational", perhaps? (never was good about that last part)

Ya, you're right. but that sends the message across the most I think.  Especially on this forum.  Over 90% of the forum is dedicated to Christianity pro or con. 

 enzo, could you post your two ideas (the rehash of the atom and the original creative design) in a png format with a transparent background? Consider that the background will be black or gray.

Nice logos.  I'm still open to ideas if anyone is considering making something.  The more the merrier.  We can always use them for banners and just give people a choice.

 Just need a little time, I'm about to head out and won't be back 'til late, hopefully sometime tomorrow.

You should get rid of the monkey to man part of the logo. Basically an oxymoron having that right next to the word rational

You should get rid of the monkey to man part of the logo. Basically an oxymoron having that right next to the word rational

Hi Brian logos are attached

This one for light backgrounds

This one for dark backgrounds

And same again.

BTW, does it suddenly smell funny in here?

Your funny comment infers so much.  I'm curious what you meant by it. 

Thanks for your contributions.  

It just stinks when a theist claims to understand the meaning of rational!

Good luck with all the logo stuff!

Just remember Brian, everyone has got an opinion, logo design is not a science it's an art. It's purely subjective there is no right and there is no wrong, there's just what people like and dislike.

You'll never make EVERYONE happy.

+1

"Facts are stupid things" *COUGH*

Not exactly what that US president meant in the 80s, but it'll do.

Sorry, but that was a spambot. Unfortunately, your post was deleted as it was a direct reply to that spambot (delete a post, and all replies go with it), so I've quoted it instead of just letting it vanish.

well this is really an impressive logo good work but IMO it would be more cool if you use the same color for the text and "evolution image".
 

just now seeing this.  i have a couple nitpicks:

the "A" logo looks a lot like the symbol of the federation in star trek.

usually a capital "A" in a circle is associated with anarchism.  i for one have never seen it associated with atheism till now.  it might throw some people.